IMF, World Bank push fiscal perks bill
By Katrina Mennen A. Valdez, Reporter
Tuesday, June 07, 2011
THE International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank prodded the Philippines to reform its fiscal incentive system amid a redundancy that has rendered tax administration inefficient in raising revenues.
In a forum, Dennis Botman, IMF resident representative, said the government should bat for the streamlining of the institutional framework, enhancement of public disclosure, narrowing the scope of incentives, and abolition of tax holidays in favor of better-targeted incentives.
This is because โtax incentives are not the most important to investors,โ he said.
Citing a survey of foreign investment decisions of Fortune 500 companies, Botman said that non-tax factors were the main determinants of their location decisions, and not the tax incentives that a country could offer to investors.
Such non-tax factors include good transportation system, good governance and enforcement of property rights, a skilled labor force, low power costs, and a supportive regulatory environment.
โTo improve the score on some of these factors, it is essential to raise government revenue. At the moment, incentives provide money to something that is less important to foreign investors, at the expense of factors that are more critical to their investment decisions,โ Botman said.
The IMF official also scored the grant of incentives to mass housing projects. โIncome tax holiday for developers of housing projects of low income earners does not necessarily promote housing for low income earners. Rather this would unduly benefit developers at the expense of other taxpayers and be prone to abuse,โ he said.
Although tax incentives carry some disadvantages, โtax holidays are particularly damaging as profits are exempted regardless of their amount,โ he said, adding that โthe most profitable investments, which would have taken place in any event, benefit the most.โ
He said that estimates for the Philippines indicate that the revenue loss from redundant incentives could be as large as one percent of gross domestic product (GDP), providing a windfall gain to receiving firms.
Instead of giving enormous incentives, Botman said these revenue resources could be used to scale up public investment, which is low by regional standards at around 3.5 percent of GDP.
GDP is the amount of final goods and services produced within the country.
The IMF official said that tax holidays invite tax avoidance through the indefinite extension of holidays via creative re-designation of existing investment as new or by encouraging transfer pricing or other devices to shift earnings to holiday companies.โThis is especially true for countries with weak revenue administration,โ he said, adding that โleakage from special economic zones is another concern.โ
Botman said the number of incentive-giving agencies in the country should be reduced as they complicate the system and often end up competing against each other.
โThere are currently about ten investment promotions agencies and several national government agencies involved in managing investment activities and administering tax incentives. This framework governing the granting and oversight of tax incentives should be streamlined,โ he said.
Incentives should be well targeted to a limited number of firms, and provided only to attract firm specific and not location-specific, internationally, mobile capital, the IMF official said.
โThis would clearly not include investments in mining or property development, as some have been lobbying for,โ he said.
Eric Le Borgne, senior economist at the World Bank in Manila, agreed with Botman, saying the government should enhance the transparency of the budget document, including all foregone revenues and make explicit the agencies that grant them.
Le Borgne raised the need to internalize the costs of tax expenditures as agencies granting tax exemptions see them as part of their budget.
Better information should also be available for improved analysis on the fiscal costs, economic impact and benefit incidence of fiscal incentives.
โThe countryโs data on fiscal incentives, and more generally on tax expenditures, are not regularly and systematically collected,โ he said.
The World Bank representative pushed for the inclusion in Fiscal Responsibility Bill the requirement to identify alternative revenue measures and/or expenditure reductions when new tax incentives are approved and identify the Department of Finance as agency in charge of estimating the cost of the proposed tax incentives.
Source: http://www.manilatimes.net/business/imf-world-bank-push-fiscal-perks-bill/
Recent surge of investments going into Clark Philippines drained Clark Freeport of prime land available for long-term leases. Investors now look for partnerships and acquisition opportunities with existing businesses located in Clark Philippines.
Three new casinos, another world-class 36-hole golf course, several new hotels and resorts of varying class of luxury have opened in Philippines Clark Freeport over the last six months. Samsung Electronics just broke ground for a US$5 billion electronics plant, coincidentally in a location adjacent to the US$2 billion plant of US chip manufacturer Texas Instruments. Hundreds of hectares of prime land in the 4200-hectare main zone of Clark Freeport have quickly been occupied. Almost the entire central business district has gone off the map of available land in this fast-growth investment destination.
With its near-zero crime rate, low pollution levels, absence of traffic congestion and a favorable tax structure, Clark Freeport is well known among foreign investors as the destination of choice. Now that the Clark International Airport (DMIA) has flung into full operations with dozens of flights linking Clark to all major cities in Asia and some beyond, Clark Freeport, Pampanga has come of age.
This web site contains articles and information that will be helpful to visitors, residents and tourists traveling out of town from Manila on a short getaway to Subic, Angeles City, Pampanga and Clark Philippines. There are several web sites that contain information that might also be pertinent to what is happening in North Luzon.
For assistance with organizing and planning weddings and garden receptions, log on to http://www.PhilippinesWeddingVenue.com
For assistance with lodgings, accommodations, hotels and resorts near Manila in Subic, Pampanga, Angels City and Clark Philippines log on to http://www.HotelClarkPhilippines.com
While in Clark, one might as well add to the itinerary a visit to the famous Clark Wine Center, the largest wine shop in Philippines which offers over 2000 selections of fine vintage wine from all wine regions, vintages spanning over 50 years covering all price ranges.
http://www.ClarkWineCenter.com
If this article about Clark is useful to you, please click here to contact us to tell us what more you wish to know about this article or Clark Philippines, which can be something about Clark investment, about Clark resorts, about Clark Swimming and Leisure or simply general news about Clark.
Please send questions to Editor@ClarkPhilippines.com. Leave your name, email address, contact numbers and we will get back to you as soon as possible. Information received will not be disclosed.
Random
Search
Contact Clark Philippines
Delectable Executive Meals
Philippine Peso Exchange Rate